QuickTopic free message boards logo
Skip to Messages


Too Much Scum Mafia Chat

(not accepting new messages)
^     All messages            90-105 of 105  74-89 >>
09:44 AM ET (US)
I agree, you did very well Log! After N1, it was basically game over unless there were two Mafia teams.

Glad to hear you enjoyed it, as I was wondering how much fun it would be when facing an insurmountable task. I was looking at it the same way. "I wonder how far he can make it!"
12:45 AM ET (US)
Thanks for hosting! If you enjoyed having me along, I enjoyed playing, and would like to continue.

If not, just let me know, I'll back out. No hard feelings :)
GornyPerson was signed in when posted
11:35 PM ET (US)
This has been an interesting game so far. TBH, you're doing pretty damn good. Being that I am the mod and I can see what other people (dead and alive) are saying, I cannot offer much advice until post game. Even if I say something innocently as advice, it wouldn't be fair to those that are still alive - and strategizing.

I think D2DC getting eaten by Noodle N1 and then Noodle getting found out and eliminated the next day worked against you, and it's only a matter of time before the town figures out what's really going on. At this point, it's a matter of lasting as long as possible. While i cannot suggest who you should try and go after, if anyone, there is however one town player that you might have a chance on getting rid of today, but then the next day it may all be over. On the other hand, things could work in your favor *if* instead you try to convince one of the town (today) to vote against one of the other two. If you can eliminate one today, then throw up some smoke and lies the next day, it's possible to still lynch two out of the three remaining town, but it's a shot in the dark I think.

All in all, you've done really well lasting this long, part of that is due to being a Mafia Godfather and no one having concrete proof as to who the real mafia is. One player is almost positive that it's you.

Your best case scenario might work or second best seems like good ideas, but if you stay out of lynching Leo, the day will end in a no lynch. As to Best case again, you would also have to jump on that train to ensure the lynch.

I think a mafia win here is a long shot, however being that it's now endgame, the time to show your cards is at hand, maybe try to go with a bluff? GL.
10:23 PM ET (US)
Any suggestions for what I can do better next time?

I think I was pretty much doomed from N1. Maybe a pro could have pulled it off, but the "confirmed neighbor chat" was an obstacle too great to overcome methinks.
09:24 PM ET (US)
That's got to be GG

Best case scenario, Leo is on board to hang Pyro, but Tears would have to turn on his ally.
Second best case, they go for Leo and I stay out of it, and the game stalemates.

All things point to this being my last night alive. I would have moved on Pyro earlier if I had seen an opportunity. I felt like creating an opening would have been to exposing.

The only thought I have at this point, is DC's claim about Leo's results from N1. It seems to me, especially after getting results from Tears, that DC gave more insight than the other reports contained. What happened? Did he make all that mess up?
10:32 AM ET (US)
I had to spice it up. If any two of Tears, Leo, and Huckit go for it, I can stay in the game. If we lynch Huckit, the game is over anyway. The way I see it, if I'm gonna go for it, it's now or never.

Plus, this is getting insanely boring. At least this will possibly generate some action.
10:00 AM ET (US)
It seems like Pyro has figured it out. Not sure why he would feel the need to take it easy on me. Have I played well enough that it's taken him this long to figure me out? Has it just taken this long for me to be in a position to have to push for a townie-lynch? I don't know.

I had a shower thought this morning, that Leo came along and confirmed my claim, supported arguments for Huckit, and we lynch. Then, next play would have to be convincing Tears to turn on Pyro, but only if Leo would support a lynch, that's my only play that could lead to a tie game. Not that I'm seriously entertaining the thought, only that my choices are just limited by the game setup.
01:57 PM ET (US)

It all makes sense in a twisted way.

Leo could be scum. Insane or not, doesn't matter as long as there is a baseline. DC was in both groups, and had to choose a side. That would be freaking amazingly awesome!
01:47 PM ET (US)

I feel like I've just binge watched 13 seasons of a show on Netflix, which ended in a very open-ended cliffhanger, and the last two seasons aren't available for streaming!
01:42 PM ET (US)
I suppose DC could have had dual membership in 2 different mafia groups... Another possible experiment.

That would certainly explain his D1 aloofness, especially here in this thread, where he should have nothing to hide, and no reason not to be open with me................................................................................................
01:38 PM ET (US)
You wouldn't have a mafia FBI agent, would you? You're not that sadistic right?

You've alluded to this game being an experiment once... You sly devil!

The inverse I think, cannot be true. What sense would an insane mafia Cop be? None that I can think of.

What tricks do you have up your sleeve Gorny!?!? :D :)
01:32 PM ET (US)
If we end up with a Huckit lynch, I have to be prepared for what could come next.

I assume the flip will be townie. I feel like the game is pretty much over at this point. The big kink in this line is, Pyro's actions (not setting his vote against Huckit, which would have been a lynch) seems like an anomaly. If he were town, and accepted that Tears is also, and believes my claim about N1 results re:Leo, and saw that Tears voted for Huckit, I know he can deduce that Tears' results claim my innocence. Either he thinks I'm Godfather, or he's not town. Based on what information I have, I can't think of any other possible outcome.

If Huckit flips scum, OMG Pyro got me. Well. F'in. Played. Sir.
01:26 PM ET (US)
I still feel as if Pyro =/= town can be true.

I also see that I am on the brink of an opportunity to push to get Pyro lynched, but with Leo M.I.A., I don't have much fuel to push with.

Think there's a chance to get Tears to flip if we lynch Huckit and he flips town. His moderate command of English, coupled with his poker knowledge, has me concerned if his statements about "I could see the possibility of Pyro being scum" as a bluff. But, there's a very small part of me that believes I could push for it successfully. I think it's all down to Leo at this point.

Without Leo coming in a making some noise, I can't really do much. If I push and explain my point of view (as a townie) that's going to look scummy. I've already played it out as not having ANY doubt that Leo will verify my claims. That seems pretty townie to me. Nothing I can do but wait it out and see.
09:41 PM ET (US)

I don't mean that I expect the game to end automatically because it is 3v1. I just suspect that both Leo and Pyro are experienced enough to know that, when Huckit flips town, I have to be the remaining scum.

If in fact, I was right this whole time, those two played one hell of a game! Color me quite impressed!
08:13 PM ET (US)
Eh, to heck with it.

If they go for it, I made it to 3v1. Then the game is over after night.

If they don't go for it, the game is over before night. Either way, good run everyone :)
09:11 AM ET (US)
Ha! That's awesome (if true!) :P

Can't wait to see how it plays out. Even though I feel like there's no hope to win, I'm having a blast just trying to stay in as long as possible. I want to try to make a move on Pyro, I feel at the very least he, and Leo, will see right through it.

Maybe with these results, I can move in. We'll see, I gotta continue to pace myself!
^     All messages            90-105 of 105  74-89 >>