QuickTopic free message boards logo
Skip to Messages

TOPIC:

GOG Mafia #52: SHODAN'S Network

^     All messages            40-55 of 55  24-39 >>
55
LifthrasilPerson was signed in when posted
11-06-2017
06:12 PM ET (US)
With the last cyborg dead, SHODAN's network falls permanently silent too.
54
LifthrasilPerson was signed in when posted
11-03-2017
08:47 PM ET (US)
Please stop posting here. Dawn is coming.
53
LifthrasilPerson was signed in when posted
11-03-2017
08:41 PM ET (US)
Noted. Dedo converts adalia
52
DedoPPerson was signed in when posted
11-03-2017
02:24 PM ET (US)
Nah, we are winning this :P
51
KrypsynPerson was signed in when posted
11-03-2017
01:02 PM ET (US)
If you don't make it through the Night, I might have to do something silly in the game thread to just see what happens.

edit: No, I haven't decided. Maybe only post with rude GIFs? Vote in alphabetical order? Only post in song lyrics? I don't know... something just really ... silly.
Edited 11-03-2017 01:03 PM
50
DedoPPerson was signed in when posted
11-03-2017
12:55 PM ET (US)
OK, here goes nothing - if I don't make it through the night - good luck!

Convert adaliabooks
49
LifthrasilPerson was signed in when posted
11-03-2017
05:02 AM ET (US)
Please decide what you do some time today.
48
DedoPPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
05:11 PM ET (US)
One other thing just occurred to me . If Wyrm is scum, depending on how tonight goes, his plan might actually be to do what I told you I'd do earlier - claim scum and try to bring us down that way.

As for the night action - yes, let me do some work, too ;)
47
KrypsynPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
04:52 PM ET (US)
Let's not call it right away, though.

I'll leave it for you then. I am assuming you still want to try for the conversion yourself? I have no problem with either of us doing it, if you have changed your mind.
46
DedoPPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
04:45 PM ET (US)
Between adaliabooks and Bookwyrm627, it is pretty even for me. I suppose we would go for the one less likely to get lynched Day 3? Both seem at risk; both have talk their way out of near lynches already.

More importantly - less likely to get hit by whatever tonight. As we saw earlier there isn't a lynch-safe person, really.I think we always want two townies out of the equation, preferably for ours to join our ranks. I agree with your expectation about HSL being among the top suspects Tomorrow, so he isn't a good option and he might actually be scum.

ZFR seems like one of the safer options for N1 conversion, so I wouldn't risk with him Tonight, I think.

If adalia/Wyrm weren't OG they should still be Town right now - Wyrm looked like he might have been a power role on D1, so they probably were afraid to go there and books was also an unsafe bet being in the spotlight as much as he did while still having all available options to work with (potentially having 2 obvious choices in flub and trent). I'd take a risk with adalia if mchack wasn't tunneling so hard on him. The only thing stopping that lynch so far was trent, I think.

That said, regardless of how much barks adalia gets, he isn't among the people who were almost lynched, so he might be a safer choice over Wyrm.

A bit of a coin flip, really, but adalia may just be the right choice.

Let's not call it right away, though. My wife is about to come home after a week long business trip during which I was looking after my boy alone, so I could use a couple of days off from the game.
45
KrypsynPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
04:26 PM ET (US)
That is my fear as well. I think we almost have to go for the conversion Tonight. Especially if one of us happens to be a NK.

For conversion, I would choose between: ZFR, Bookwyrm627, and adaliabooks

ZFR is risky, as he would have been a good choice for the Mutant on Night 1. He also might be a Mason, if he/they have been particularly devious.

Between adaliabooks and Bookwyrm627, it is pretty even for me. I suppose we would go for the one less likely to get lynched Day 3? Both seem at risk; both have talk their way out of near lynches already.

Do you have a better suggestion?

edit: I think I would lean towards adaliabooks for the coversion. Just a gut feeling. As I have stated, though, my reads have been poor all game.
Edited 11-02-2017 04:28 PM
44
DedoPPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
04:16 PM ET (US)
Trent is and will remain dead set on me. He's stubborn like that, I saw it last game. I don't mind that though.

Do you think the other team will try to kill rather than convert? I'd say tonight is probably the last night conversions can happen. If we kill Town and the other team converts successfully I think we might not be able to catch up anymore.
43
KrypsynPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
04:10 PM ET (US)
Well, we would want to kill a Mutant or a 'confirmed' townie, while causing as much confusion as possible. Mchack shouldn't die, because he seems to be directing his efforts away from us presently. HypersomniacLive should be left alive, because he is an obvious target Day 3 for lynch.

Trentonlf might be a good option, as he is at the very least confirmed town, if not a Mason. However, his reads seem to be on mostly other players (although, he did have concerns over you, iirc). If he has concerns for me, they haven't been stated much, if at all. Worst case is that he was the recruit Night 2, so that wouild cause much confusion (since that would destroy the 3 Cyborg vs 1 Mutant theory).

My first pick would have been Sage103082, as I am fairly confident she is a Mason (and she wasn't posting as much). However, I don't really want to kill a replacement right after he has spent all that time catching up. Bad play strategically, maybe, but it is just a game and I don't really want to be a jerk about it.

We also have to consider who the other team may try to NK (if that is their agenda Night 2). I would rather kill 2, than both of us target the same person.

edit: Heck, one of us may even be the NK target for the other team. I see both of us as good options for the Mutants.
Edited 11-02-2017 04:13 PM
42
DedoPPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
03:48 PM ET (US)
OK, about the kill - what are we looking to get out of it if we decide for a kill?
41
KrypsynPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
01:18 PM ET (US)
Also, what do you make of him saying he has his D3 planned already?

I found it ambiguous. It could mean anything. It could be town that doesn't want to let on about a strategy, it could be scum just wanting to leave himself some wiggle room (can say anything was your plan, after the fact, after all). Regardless, it was designed to leave his options open, or at least hidden. I really can't read into it any more than that. I could see it coming from both a town Bookwyrm627 and a scum Bookwyrm627.
40
DedoPPerson was signed in when posted
11-02-2017
12:23 PM ET (US)
See, your input is valuable! I didn't consider Wyrm changeing his stance on roles talk, I'm mostly winging it from memory. That said, maybe he changed his mind because of mchack's claim? I have to agree that once that happened and there wasn't a counter-claim the pool of Mason posibilities decreased drastically. Most people who were paying attention would probably figure out most of what Wyrm wrote by themselves. His post actually helped me since I was lazy enough not to try and figure things out myself for some things, but I'm pretty sure I would have been able to connect at least some dots if I tried. So, did he spilled anything really or did he just pointed everyone's attention to what was already available for everyone who was looking? I think he is probably Town and might be looking for a recruitment :D

Also, what do you make of him saying he has his D3 planned already?
^     All messages            40-55 of 55  24-39 >>

Print | RSS Views: 202 (Unique: 25 ) / Subscribers: 0 | What's this?