QuickTopic free message boards logo
Skip to Messages

TOPIC:

FAITH AND SAYAKA: MANHUNTERS MAFIA

^     All messages            61-76 of 76  45-60 >>
76
Jazz
12-21-2019
11:45 AM ET (US)
Let me know when you get online, we can hammer sage for gg
75
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
02:13 PM ET (US)
also scum wants to know who the BP is so they don't waste nk on them. They just let them live till lylo and let them lose by game mechanics.
74
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
02:07 PM ET (US)
claim BP out of the blue isn't good. You need someone else to demand claims before you do it.
73
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
02:07 PM ET (US)
he setting up his cohort for claiming BP

no matter how you look at it, claiming here is bad as town. it makes sense yesterday when scum has to claim vt because they don't know the set up, but today it makes no sense to claim.
72
Jazz
12-20-2019
02:05 PM ET (US)
Because if Tgt was scum he would just know this and claim BP?
71
Jazz
12-20-2019
02:05 PM ET (US)
I think that post is fine but I don’t think you can argue TGT is scum for asking for claims
70
Jazz
12-20-2019
02:04 PM ET (US)
I would be careful about claiming BP. It’s possible someone else has that flavor and they are vanilla. The dennis frogman role was supposed to be cop but faith had it and she was vanilla
69
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
01:59 PM ET (US)
im gonna follow it up with a 'TGT should have know this, so scum'
68
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
01:59 PM ET (US)
check this for me before i scum slip

scum is the only group that for sure knows the entire set up, because they now know malcolms role and whichever role they have, so they know if we're in BP + scumblock+ jail or in jail + vanilla + vanilla. Scum can easily fake claim if we're in either one. If we have BP they know the set up too, but we can't trust what BP claim says.


Problem with claiming is that scum can claim whatever the hell they want. They can claim the 1 shot BP and town can't counter claim if we're in JVV. If we're in BSJ they can easily counter claim to try to force a town lynch.


At this point in time, if we do have a bulletproof and it hasn't been used, it's best they keep their mouth shut so it might come up later. If we have BP and they've used it claiming gains us nothing. Claims either way could be a mafia fake claim because they would know if we're in JVV but we don't know if we are or not, because aside from the person with bulletproof we don't know which one we're in.
67
Jazz
12-20-2019
01:58 PM ET (US)
Yes Gemstone. For all they know we could have a roleblocker and then we’d be in column A I think with a BP

That’s why Tyranno wants BP to claim
66
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
01:53 PM ET (US)
just to confirm before I info slip: town jailer is the only role town knows for sure right?
65
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
01:53 PM ET (US)
ftr claiming here as town is super bad.
64
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
01:46 PM ET (US)
fuck it im shutting down all claims to avoid someone lying about claims.
63
GemstoneMine
12-20-2019
01:42 PM ET (US)
im super tempted to claim BP
62
Jazz
12-20-2019
08:48 AM ET (US)
Third times the charm
61
Jazz
12-20-2019
08:48 AM ET (US)
NK Malcolm 100%
^     All messages            61-76 of 76  45-60 >>

Print | RSS Views: 105 (Unique: 18 ) / Subscribers: 0 | What's this?