QuickTopic (SM) free message boards QuickTopic (SM) free message boards
Skip to Messages
  Sign In to access your topic list  |New Topic |My Topics|Profile
Upgrade to Pro   Customize, show pictures, add an intro, and more:   QuickTopic Pro...and check out QuickThreadSM
Topic: Melancholy Elephants: a copyright parable
Views: 436, Unique: 337 
Subscribers: 1
What's
this?
Printer-Friendly Page
Subscribe to get & post, or stop messages by email Subscribe
All messages            8-8 of 8  1-7 >>
About these ads
Who | When
Messagessort recent-bottom   
Post a new message
 
cypherpunksPerson was signed in when posted  8
09-05-2002 06:15 PM ET (US)
My reaction is just the opposite. I enjoyed the writing, as I do with most of Robinson's stories, but I thought the premise about copyright was laughably absurd.

Supposedly there is only a finite number of songs, stories, etc., so authors and artists will be shut down because everything will have been done before. Therefore we not only need to limit the time span of copyright, we need to be sure that we forget old art so that we don't realize that new art is a retread of the old.

That's ridiculous; the number of permutations possible for colors, notes, words, is practically unlimited. The story demonstrates a fundamental innumeracy in failing to understand that the number of possible works of art is far greater than the number of atoms in the universe. We are in no danger of running out of ideas, whether copyright is extended or not.

Besides, the notion of restricting copyright just to encourage artists to submit retreads of tired old ideas is abysmally stupid. Art should be novel and creative, not a warmed-over rehash.
RSS link What's this?
All messages            8-8 of 8  1-7 >>
QuickTopicSM message boards
Over 200,000 topics served
Learn more Frequently asked questions  Acknowledgements
What they're saying about QuickTopic
 Questions, comments, or suggestions? Contact Us
Read our use policy before beginning. We value your privacy; please read our privacy statement.
Copyright ©1999-2008 Internicity Inc. All rights reserved.