| Hector Jasso
|
7
|
 |
|
04-16-2001 01:02 PM ET (US)
|
|
I also have my doubts about how appropriate the Precision/Recall-Breakeven Point is for measuring effectiveness of a text retrieval algorithm. Although it is a common measure for evaluating text classifiers, as the authors mention, they introduce a new definition for their algorithm! Or at least they should talk about how the confidence value for Naive Bayes classifiers/SVM translates to the corresponding measure in TSVM's, which was just defined as the point where the number of false positives being equal to number of false negatives.
On a different point, I see a parallel between this paper and the one on boosting image retrieval in that they both talk about sparse problem instances. And I think that although it is valid to derive new algorithms for these types of problems, care should be taken as to the type of benchmarks that are appropriate for testing.
|