QuickTopic (SM) free message boards QuickTopic (SM) free message boards
Skip to Messages
  Sign In to access your topic list  |New Topic |My Topics|Profile
Upgrade to Pro   Customize, show pictures, add an intro, and more:   QuickTopic Pro...and check out QuickThreadSM
Topic: Coming Home
Printer-Friendly Page
About these ads
Who | When
Messagessort recent-bottom    (not accepting new messages)
Ginger  37
11-17-2004 10:49 PM ET (US)
Why not think about how we are treating people we are professing to liberate? I don't think there is a single person who plans on disrespecting a soldier - their sacrifice and commitment is obvious. What is not obvious is the truth about why were asked to fight this war. Why not talk about that part? Don't you wonder how straight the media (CNN, Fox, MSNBC) is really being with you? The harsh truth is that they are NOT telling you why we went to war. They are protecting their own interests - and not the general public's.

It's up to all of you to find out the true meaning of this war. If you care about why our men and women are out there, stop listening to the pundits and start listening to your gut. Ask questions - and don't let yourself be talked down to - by anyone.
mary  36
11-17-2004 06:44 PM ET (US)
thanks kevin for this source of photos and stories direct from iraq.
i will be checking here for info i hope is unbiased.
 
Messages 35-32 deleted by topic administrator 11-18-2004 12:12 AM
Gerald Buckley  31
05-01-2004 09:44 PM ET (US)
I like this kevin sites blog, but I won't be a part of this discussion. It should be edited.
samantha  30
04-21-2004 01:38 AM ET (US)
how were men treated that did not go to war in ww1
   29
04-12-2004 08:21 AM ET (US)
Deleted by topic administrator 11-18-2004 12:12 AM
Esperanza  28
03-17-2004 03:46 PM ET (US)
I agree with Elle, what is wrong with you lamp?
War is the most horrible thing in the world but someone must defend the helpless and oppressed of the world. If you like your freedom, chances are someone along the way died for it. Putos like you would never have stood up for freedom and democracy and we'd all be living in some despot's private hell-hole right now.
The Spanish, Americans, British etc in Iraq right now are heroes. They should be treated as such.
Elle  27
02-27-2004 08:32 AM ET (US)
Lamp:

What is wrong with you???? First of all, not everyone who went over to Vietnam or Iraq .... necessarily killed people. For God's sake, my dad was on an aircraft carrier -- he just knows many of the pilots who left, never came back. Second of all, do you really think that the soldiers go to war with happy thoughts of killing people! Be real. Would you rather, when faced with another pointing gun your way ready to shoot, that these men lay down their gun and be killed????

I am not for this war -- I never was. I always thought is was simply a Bush Family vendetta / best interests war having to do with oil. And I never wanted any of our men to go over there. But the fact is that they are over there and regardless of how I feel about the over all war, I would always support our people over there!!! For many, it is not a choice whether to go or not go -- and I would never cast stones on a man for defending himself.

Maybe you should rethink your BS.
lamp  26
02-18-2004 03:27 PM ET (US)
"I also worry about how the media will handle them. I still remember all too clearly their reaction to Timothy McVeigh and John Mohammed (the Washington Sniper). Sadly, it only takes on vet doing something stupid to make the rest of us look like Rambos in waiting."

You ARE a bunch of Rambos in waiting. Someone(the gov.) gives you $1000 a month, or whatever crap pay you get and you're willing to slaughter brown people all day long. The difference is only in what country you're killing people. It wasn't "one vet doing something stupid" that gave you guys a bad name, it was the millions of you dumb fucks that have been killing people all over the globe for the last 50 years that did it. get a fucking clue: people are people-- killing Iraqi's or Vietnamese is just as bad as killing Americans.
lamp  25
02-18-2004 03:20 PM ET (US)
"I hope our current soldiers will not expeience the "shame" that your father and mine experienced.... I hope they can hold their heads up high..... I wish for them the strength that you so obviously have..... and I certainly wish for them and for our country that no one stands in judgement of these men....."

Fuck that. If you're a murderer you should feel ashamed! Honor is reserved for those who make hard choices-- going along with a murderous war makes you just as bad as the people who's idea it was. stop coddling these moral degenerates. they aren't real men and shouldn't be treated as such.
lamp  24
02-18-2004 03:14 PM ET (US)
This was a good story. It showed how amoral our soldiers are. They don't give a crap about defending democracy, they just joined up cause they had dead end lives. and now they're distraught cause they didn't have the moral backbone to not kill people who did nothing to them. cool shit
Dick  23
02-09-2004 06:44 PM ET (US)
Four friends who'd readjusted from special warfare (1960's) to civilian life relapsed occasionally. Examples:
1. Gutting a live trout
2. Attacking when his wife approached from behind
3. Justifying a live cap in a training booby trap
4. Admiring an Apache method of torture
5. Boasting of air-dropping a zealot to make a weakling talk
6. Repeating a cannibalistic lyric
Only one repented. ALL had refused to re-enlist.
Dick, Salt Lake City, Utah
debbie  22
02-09-2004 12:17 PM ET (US)
I remember well how our men were treated upon returning from Vietnam. Some were shamefull, some were proud, but all seemed angry. The country did them a great dis-service. The biggest difference then was the draft. These men did not want to fight then anymore than now, but the government said go...and they did their jobs. Many never came back, and those who did were scared for life. I was sadly married to one of those men. A "tunnel-rat", and I would wake up with a pillow held to my face, or fingers around my neck. Sometimes the yelling and thrashing would come first. He wouldn't talk of what happened over there, but it haunted him all the time. The blind fury would creep over him and hold him by the neck, till he would strike out, or submitt to weeping. Sadly, we eventually went our own way, but the war to this day still haunts him. We take young men, boys for the most part, and in that time they are in Iraq, the rest of their lives will be altered. Some will be strong enough to handle it, many won't. How they will be treated when they return will have more of an impact than those of us here can begin to imagine. I pray that the government will back them up and continue to offer them support to overcome the brutality of war. But ultimately it will be up to us to extend the hand and welcome them back. Let them know that we support them, regardless of how we felt about the war. It's so easy for those here to say the war is wrong. Tell that to the people of Irag, who have looked our men in the eyes and thanked them for setting them free. Tell that to our boys and men who have seen first hand what is happening, and to the families who have lost loved ones. "War is Hell", no matter where you are, who you are and what position you hold on it. But sadly in this day and age, it's also a fact of life.
Thomas in Japan  21
02-08-2004 07:49 AM ET (US)
Thought provoking. Intense feelings. I wonder if, as time goes by and more and more of the national guard is circulated through these kinds of experiences and return to society they will intensify the identity of "American first, and everyone else should be grateful for it." Our guys may have done their best, but there is always another side or sides. Will anyone care about that, when they can easily identify with someone from their church or community who has returned from "fighting terrorists" as the story will probably be told. Who can sympathise with someone who isn't American, and doesn't necessarily appreciate what our foreign policy has done "for them"? From my experience, growing up in "small town USA" not many people will, I'm sure.
My greatest sympathy is with the folks in the guards units. I don't know if they expected this kind of thing when they signed up.
Gerald Buckley  20
02-06-2004 08:47 PM ET (US)
Great story about the soldiers, very touching. This war is much more dangerous than the 1st gulf war, and my heart goes out to the soldiers. I wish the media would pump these guys up more, instead of simply giving the daily body count. Do you think there is hope for this country? Can it be healed from the awful legacy of Saddam? Should we leave?
I'll put your site on my list of favorites. Thank you for your great work.
Elle  19
01-29-2004 11:18 PM ET (US)
Steven,

Thank you for your reply. My father served two terms in Vietnam... well in the Navy on an aircraft carrier. I never knew this until I was much older. He never spoke of it... until one day it came up in a conversation and my mother was saying how when my father had leave, she asked he boss for a week off of work to go and visit him and she was fired because she was married to a "baby killer". In fact, as I said, my father was on an aircraft carrier and did not (thankfully) see all the horrors of the war... but in his words: "We watched a lot of planes take off with fine pilots / men that never returned." When I asked my mother and father why they never spoke of my father's time in Nam, he said it very simply, because people are ill informed and prejudiced and they had a family to raise and did not need any undue stresses in trying to do so. I understand.

I hope our current soldiers will not expeience the "shame" that your father and mine experienced.... I hope they can hold their heads up high..... I wish for them the strength that you so obviously have..... and I certainly wish for them and for our country that no one stands in judgement of these men.....

Anyway... I am a bit on a soap box... and I do not know why...... So I wish to you all a good evening.... a great weekend... I can;t believe Friday is already here.....

Isn;t it interesting how a year ago we were all so aware of what was happening over there... and now you almost have to search for the news???? Hmmm.....
Steven Francis Murphy  18
01-28-2004 10:22 PM ET (US)
Elle,

Thanks for the thoughts. To play a bit of Devil's Advocate, I tend to ride high in the saddle, as it were. My father, who was a Vietnam draftee himself, strongly advised that when I started college that I keep my military past to myself. Shove it into a closet, as it were.

I didn't, in fact, I tend to do the exact opposite. I tend to let everyone know I served. I don't embelish. I didn't do anything more special than pull guard duty for a Headquarters Battery in an Artillery Battalion. Maybe if my war had been, oh, harder on me, I'd behave differently.

That said, I did run into a fair amount of prejudice. Whether or not it is wide spread among Operation Desert Storm vets is not something I can speak to.

The only reason I even bring it up here is that we are talking about our newest generation of veterans (who have been through a hell of a lot more than I went through). I worry deeply about their treatment.

I also worry about how the media will handle them. I still remember all too clearly their reaction to Timothy McVeigh and John Mohammed (the Washington Sniper). Sadly, it only takes on vet doing something stupid to make the rest of us look like Rambos in waiting.

My father, by the way, was treated much worse than I was.

Thanks again, Elle.

Respects,
Steven Francis Murphy
Elle  17
01-28-2004 11:50 AM ET (US)
To Steven Francis Murphy,

I am a 34 year old female - who at the time Vietnam ws ending was but a mere child - and I can never really recall what happened to our men when they came back from the war - but I know very well through documentation and readings of the frightful and unjust treatment. What surprised me most of what you wrote - was that you expereinced some of the same once you were settling back into civilan life after the Gulf War in the early 90's. I believe you, of course, because unfrotunately we all meet those individuals who can not take a moment to think beyond themselves, but I find it so unsettling. It is goes back to the statement of never judge a person til you have walked in their shoes..... but here I am preaching to the choir.... I just wanted to tell you that I was never one of those ignorant people who sat in judgement of you or the job you did - or the job our soliders are doing now. I applaud your courage and the sacrifce you made (and our current soldiers are making) for me and my freedom - for the country that I love. saying that - I must say that I was not for the first gulf war, nor was I in favor of this second fiasco - however, that would never give me the audacity to criticize the job that my fellow americans are doing over there. Mr. Murphy, I applaud you and congratulate you - for all that you have done and all that you will do - knowing it is all your expereinces that make you the person you are today. Special.

Kevin - Thank you - again - for your personal account and contribution. Stay safe!
sara  16
01-27-2004 10:55 PM ET (US)
recently rediscovered your site as the upcoming visit of a friend who works for cnn brought you to mind. so glad to find that your blog is active again--i have a great deal of catching up to do! thank you and stay safe!
Steven Francis Murphy  15
01-27-2004 09:20 PM ET (US)
As our soldiers return from Iraq, replaced by their peers, I find myself wondering the following:

1. How will these new veterans be treated by the civilian population, especially on college campuses?

2. Will the Media actually take the time to discuss the causal reasons why a soldier, be it male or female, uses the "killer switch" on a spouse? Or will it simply make money off of the tried and true headline, "Soldier goes nuts, kills wife and kids."

Being a veteran of the First Gulf War, I recall that we were treated very well.

Initially.

However, over time, especially once I left the Army to go to college, I found that many of the old Vietnam era stereotypes and prejudices were still very much alive.

Common questions included the following:

1. Why didn't you get a real job, instead of joining the Army for college money?

2. Did you kill anyone?

3. How does it feel to prostitute your body out to the Army for college money?

Then toss in the usual expletives and slurs about babykilling, mental illness and the like.

So, having been through that, I wonder how America will treat these new veterans of an arguably tougher war?

I have a bad feeling that some of them, especially when they get out and start college, are going to find out.

Respects,
Steven Francis Murphy
U.S. Army 1989 to 1993
North Kansas City, Missouri
irma  14
01-27-2004 08:37 PM ET (US)
You are truly bringing the reality of war with your pictures and stories. My heart goes out to these young soldiers who are America's new veterans. How I wish I could help them erase the horrors they have experienced. All we can do is try to understand them with open eyes and heart. And hope for a better tomorrow for them and our country's future.
Kelly Ricciardi  13
01-27-2004 06:55 PM ET (US)
That was so nice to read and to see. My Husband is in Iraq now and I have no clue what he is going through. All I know is my children and I miss him and pray everyday for his safe return. Thank you for the insight.
Ashley Deemer  12
01-27-2004 01:28 PM ET (US)
It makes me wonder what makes a true soldier. All the blood shed and dying, or all the times promises to go home are broken, or perhaps maybe even a wife or girl friend that decided a week after her soldier left that she was not with him anymore. Leaves him to fight alone.I admire all our soldiers in Iraq and I say they have all done a great job. I hope they are okay when they finally return home.I respect seeing a story with feeling in it..great job buddy!Thanks
Jason Brian  11
01-27-2004 01:11 AM ET (US)
Mr. Sites,
  I have loved your updates. It make what we're (you guys) doing seem real. Not like the mainstream media partrays us as doing. I have had family doing the duties of the armed srevices in wars past, but have not fully realized that these are real men, like myself doing and seeing things they never really thought happened on our great planet. You brought it home. Thanks! And thanks to all you brave men and women who did the deed for us. You know... It HAD to be done.
Tony Hertz  10
01-26-2004 11:21 PM ET (US)
Thanks for being our eyes and ears over there Kevin. Great work. Take care of yourself.
Mike Hoogendyk  9
01-26-2004 07:01 PM ET (US)
Of all the news sources we have, your amazing on-line column with astounding photos is the one that is most personal, most informative and most appreciated. Thank you so much and keep up the great work!
MikeR  8
01-26-2004 05:26 PM ET (US)
Thank you. In my blog just yesterday I complained about lazy reporters. You, obviously, aren't one of them.

My youngest son is one of the replacements for these men. He, too, is 82nd and arrived in Baghdad three weeks ago. He already spent 9 months in Afghanistan, and understands the environment, although the mission is now different. Your photos and writing bring him closer to me.
Eric Blair  7
01-26-2004 04:12 PM ET (US)
Good stuff. Keep it up.
pj48  6
01-26-2004 03:40 PM ET (US)
I have to say the second, third, fifth, sixth, seventh and eigth pictures say more than a lot of articles I have read.

It makes me wish there was more ways the American public could help.
Kelly  5
01-26-2004 02:38 PM ET (US)
Thank you for the pictures and the essay that goes along with it. I'm a military wife of almost 20 years and I have a feeling there will be a lot of divorces on the soldiers return home. So sad that perhaps the one thing that kept them going an entire year will fall apart when they do finally return home. The price a soldier pays is much higher than what the general public is aware..it isn't only in blood and death they pay, but their whole life can be changed forever.

I saw a change in my husband when he returned from the first Gulf War...I wonder what other changes will have taken place this time when he has seen so much more this time around (and hopefully last). I look forward to his return...and I don't...horrible of me to say? Its just experience talking here after deployments to Panama, the 1st Gulf, Somolia and two tours in Korea...I know we have months maybe even years of hard work a head of us. That is the reality.
Deb Wolf  4
01-26-2004 02:28 PM ET (US)
The innocense of children......... makes me wonder what is happening to children that have lost their parents? Perhaps an adoption program, there are so many couples that want to adopt. Just curious.
Ann Marie  3
01-26-2004 01:54 PM ET (US)
Thanks for the wonderful pictures...

Keep up the good work Kevin!

Most Fondly,

Ann Marie
teri  2
01-26-2004 11:31 AM ET (US)
Nice photos. It is so good to see smiling faces. That is so very good!
Julio Cesar Martinez  1
01-26-2004 11:28 AM ET (US)
Orale ese, nice work and detail telling stuff coming from your head homes, I like it very much and I realize the seriousness of your work, saludos a ti and your work ese.
RSS link What's this?
QuickTopicSM message boards
Over 200,000 topics served
Learn more Frequently asked questions  Acknowledgements
What they're saying about QuickTopic
 Questions, comments, or suggestions? Contact Us
Read our use policy before beginning. We value your privacy; please read our privacy statement.
Copyright ©1999-2008 Internicity Inc. All rights reserved.