Edited by author 02-12-2004 02:56 PM
Selma asks on the NDD General Topic forum:
I just came across the different (new) forums you have started and read them. At this one I read something about John Holt. So, could you name titles of books of John Holt about Unschooling? Selma
Hi Selma,
A bit of personal synchronicity here. I also remembered a reference to John Holt, somewhere, and I went to sleep last night thinking I want to read his book on unschooling.
My wife and I were very enthusiastic about his works when we were raising our son. His books How Children Fail and "How Children Learn", are absolutely great. Other influences were JS Neils Summerhill, Haim Ginotts Between Parent and Child, Rudolf Steiner, and Sylvia Aston-Warners Teacher. Teacher stands out for me as perhaps among my top three favorite books ever read. Anyone who likes kids just gotta read it.
Anyway, I checked with Amazon and came up with Teach Your Own --- The John Holt Book of Homeschooling pub. 2003 as the latest release. One reviewer writes:
In this unofficial treatise for the homeschooling movement, John Holt, longtime private school teacher, maintains that the traditional classroom model no longer works and may, in fact, ruin kids for learning. He exhorts parents to challenge the conventional wisdom and be their children's teachers. You don't need to be a homeschooler to benefit from Holt's books; you simply need to care about children and education and to have uttered, if only once, "There's got to be a better way."
I think there is usually a distinction made between homeschooling and unschooling, and I didnt find a title with the latter. Anyway I am going to take a trip to the library and see if I cant find Teach Your Own. When I mentioned unschooling to my wife, she responded by saying Wendy's Heather on the EarthStar forum is the best example she could think of after purveiwing her pages on the Peace and Carrots website. I am not sure she fits such a category but I would guess so, given her independent, dynamic character and the other outstanding results. Our own son quit public school in the seventh grade and certainly does not seem to have suffered from it. The 'education' from experiences he sought out from then on, on his own, set him in much better stead than sitting in a classroom ever could have done, we believe.
Most of these forums as you say are just now starting. I just added a new one, titled 'New Education' I somehow had overlooked, though it is one of the major headings in the newdaydawning.org website I am beginning to assemble. It will eventually be accesable from
http://newdaydawning.org/neweducation/neweducationforum.htm Jerry,
Thanks for your answer.
I understood unschooling as: de-schooling = free one/myself of aaaaaall the useless stuff I learned at school and "grieving over" the maaaaany unpleasant houres of being school-jailed (I guess I invented a new word!!!)yep...
I like the "rule" in education which Mrs. Montessori used as her basic in teaching: "teach me to do it myself".
Although her attitude towards educating children was a big step forward in child-friendly-education those days, I would have liked it to be a pupil at a school with the phrase: "give me the freedom and space to do (learn) it my way".
Well, as long as adults claim to know what someone (child) needs to know/learn, there will be a lot of drilling in teaching. Funny to see that more and more children can't cope in this system. So the system finally will change...
Just some thoughts..
Selma