This response is from a MEGA member and is very detailed and I thought it would be helpful for you to see this prior to November 21. I have her permission to share with you'll.
Thanks for your note, Martha.
I have taken some time to review the draft and am extremely impressed with its
content. In almost all cases, I believe that these objectives/goals can be
implemented into the standard curriculum almost seamlessly - and that was not
small feat in the curriculum design process, I'm sure!
Except for a few typo-like errors, I have only a few small questions/comments
about curriculum objectives:
The grades 5, 6, and 8, strand 1, objective 1 (spreadsheet rows 136, 169,
and 246) include the phrase "visually represent" in the objective relating to
changes in technology. The visual representation would require some sort of
project as I interpret this objective, and I question the importance of doing
the visual representation in all three grades. I would suggest that the
"visual representation" terminology be deleted from all but grade 8. Even
then, it may be difficult to incorporate into the standard curriculum,but
could easily be implemented with the Business Computer Technology curriculum
that many students take as an elective.
The second question relates to the timing of the keyboarding instruction
(strand 4, obj 3). I wholehearted concur with the timing; however, having
taught keyboarding, I know that a child needs daily practice for a minimum of
25 minutes a day for approximately nine weeks to truly internalize/synthesize
proper technique. This objective will be extremely difficult to implement in
the 4th grade with the shortage of computer labs and computer teachers in the
elementary schools. (I do not believe that a regular classroom teacher can
effectively teach this objective, and that it really needs to be taught by
someone with an understanding of keyboarding methods.) At the same time - the
6th grade is truly too late for almost half of the students that I work with.
By the 6th grades, many students have become so proficient with hunt and peck
typing, that they refuse to slow-down enough to retrain themselves with proper
technique. (This is truly a catch 22 dilemma. The objective needs additional
funding in order to effectively implement it at the 4th grade level.)
In the database objective (2.3) starting in the third grade, there is mention
of "searching" databases. I know that Wake County and many other systems uses
Microsoft Works due to ease of use in teaching databases to our younger
students. Works uses the term "filter" instead of "search." Would it be
possible to state this objective as "search/filter"?
I love the way that you have incorporated other curricular areas into the
objectives. On line 236 - the seventh grade curriculum - did you know that
the new social studies curriculum also includes the inclusion of Australia in
the study of the Eastern Hemisphere?
Line 237, includes IP address among the terms/concepts for 7th grade. I
suspect that most teachers would not know what an IP address is, and question
the importance of including this term at the 7th grade level. (It would be
great to include if we had a technology curriculum that spanned into high
school!)
I'm assuming that you really wanted feedback relating to content, but knowing
how difficult it is for me to catch my own typographical errors, I'll point
out the small handful that I noticed:
Line 84 - a "b" is located at the end of "that."
Line 119 - there is a word missing at the end of the objective, possibly
"class."
In column E, there are several objectives that probably need to be renumbered
to reflect a different grade level. See lines 166, 168, 201, 202, 203, 229,
238, 240, and 245.
As I said in my note on Friday, thanks SO MUCH for asking for input from the
field! I enjoyed the early exposure to our new technology objectives.
Have a great week!
Diane
____________________________
Diane Walters
Curriculum Integration Coordinator
West Millbrook Middle School
8115 Strickland Road
Raleigh, NC 27615
Voice: 919-676-5019
FAX: 919-870-4064
dwalters@wcpss.net
------------------( Forwarded letter 1 follows )--------------------
Date: Fri, 14 Nov 2003 16:53:27 -0500
To: dwalters
From: mcampbel@dpi.state.nc.us
Subject: Re: Ancillary materials for technology curriculum
Diane,
Thank you so much for your response and all the work you have done. You will love MEGA it is a great place to be. The Draft s still a work in progress and we would love to have your input. I look forward to meeting you.
Have fab weekend!
Best,
Martha Campbell
Martha Campbell
Information/Computer Skills Consultant
Instructional Services Division
North Carolina Department of Public Instruction
6353 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699
919.807.3868
All email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the
North Carolina Public Records law, which may result in monitoring and
disclosure to third parties, including law enforcement.
>>> "DIANE WALTERS" <DWALTERS@wcpss.net> 11/14/03 02:36PM >>>
Martha,
I am a new member of MEGA, and just received a message from Becky Reed
suggesting that members send information to you regarding ancillary materials
that we may be using to help our students prepare for the NC Computer Skills
Test. I have created a portal page (layered within my husband's business
web-site) that has links to outstanding material created by teachers and
technology facilitators all over the state. You may be aware of these pages,
but you may want to take a look in case there are some that you are not
familiar with. The link is:
http://www.raleighlocksmith.com/wmms_cic/student/skillstest.htm Also, if you are not familiar with Harnett County's "Survivor 4 - It's a
Jungle Out There" handbook, I strongly encourage you to touch base with Martha
Hurd in Harnett County's central office. It is an outstanding handbook that
Harnett County students are given prior to the test for review purposes. It
helps to meet many of the needs of students who do not have access to a home
computer.
Thanks for asking those in the field to voice their opinion. I'll review the
new draft of the technology curriculum as time permits over the weekend.
Diane Walters
Curriculum Integration Coordinator
West Millbrook Middle School
8115 Strickland Road
Raleigh, NC 27615
Voice: 919-676-5019
FAX: 919-870-4064
dwalters@wcpss.net