I am so glad that we read Beloved. This is the second time reading it for me and although I would not have done that by own choice I am glad I did because I actually enjoyed it this time. I think that by discussin the moral rights and wrongs about Sethe's actions is wasting time. If we spend all of our time focusing on that we miss that bigger picture. There are so many levels and so many issues to discuss that we should not just stop there, on the very surface of the book to analyze it. The fact is, Sethe did kill her baby, so let's move on. Did anyone wonder about the last chapter? I think that is one of the most interesting parts, especially now for the second time I have mor einsights into the meaning.